Florida State University Law Review
specialized law reviews, journal prestige, methodology, author-prominence ranking
Law | Legal Education | Legal Writing and Research
We thank Greg Crespil and Russell Korobkin for their provocative responses to our author-prominence ranking of specialized law reviews. Crespi provides a thoughtful critique of the methodology we employ and the results we obtained. Korobkin shares some of Crespi's concerns, but he focuses his critique on the potential implications of our rankings (and rankings more generally). In this reply, we briefly address the more significant criticisms each of them raises.
Tracey E. George and Chris Guthrie,
In Defense of Author Prominence: A Reply to Crespi and Korobkin, 26 Florida State University Law Review. 877
Available at: https://scholarship.law.vanderbilt.edu/faculty-publications/860