Document Type


Publication Title

Seton Hall Law Review

Publication Date


Page Number



probability, juries, weight of evidence, surprise, burden of proof


Evidence | Law | Probability


In this Symposium issue celebrating his career, Professor Michael Risinger in Leveraging Surprise proposes using "the fundamental emotion of surprise" as a way of measuring belief for purposes of legal proof. More specifically, Professor Risinger argues that we should not conceive of the burden of proof in terms of probabilities such as 51%, 95%, or even "beyond a reasonable doubt." Rather, the legal system should reference the threshold using "words of estimative surprise" -asking jurors how surprised they would be if the fact in question were not true. Toward this goal (and being averse to cardinality), he suggests categories such as "mildly surprised, surprised, quite surprised, greatly surprised, astonished, shocked, etc." We find Professor Risinger's proposal intriguing. After all, one can imagine important theoretical reasons why surprise might generate different results from probability. To the extent that the surprise formulation is unfamiliar, it might cause jurors to think holistically ("System 1") as opposed to attempting to use rules (often misremembered or misapplied) about probability ("System 2"). Surprise might be easier to approach qualitatively, unlike probability, which cries out for quantitative calculation and invokes the fear of numbers for some. Surprise is also notably framed in the negative ("How surprised would you be if the fact were not true?") compared to its probability counterpart ("What is the probability that the fact is true?"). Being empiricists, we thus could not help but put Professor Risinger's worthy proposal to the test, if only in a preliminary way.



To view the content in your browser, please download Adobe Reader or, alternately,
you may Download the file to your hard drive.

NOTE: The latest versions of Adobe Reader do not support viewing PDF files within Firefox on Mac OS and if you are using a modern (Intel) Mac, there is no official plugin for viewing PDF files within the browser window.